Booklist Online - Disgrace, by J. M. Coetzee (REVIEW)
Booklist Online

Booklist Online: Book Reviews from the American Library Association

| | | | | | | | |
Quick Search
Perform Quick Search
Go to Advanced Search
Current Issue
   NOVEMBER 15, 2009

      BOOKLIST

Spotlight on Religion &    Spirituality
He Reads . . . Faith
She Reads . . . Faith
Top 10 Books in Religion    & Spirituality: 2009
Carte Blanche: The Last    Taboo?
Top 10 Religion Books for    Youth: 2009
Top 10 Religion Video:    2009

Features
Booklist Online Chat    Room: New and    Improved
Another Look at: SIRS    Issues Researcher
RA Corner: Gary Warren    Niebuhr's Caught Up in    Crime
Fall Database Update    Part 2; Changes to    Existing Databases;    2009

The Back Page

Browse Reviews

WEB EXCLUSIVES

At Length with Edward    Humes
Booklist Video: Margo    Lanagan
Booklist Video: E. Lockhart
Booklist Video: Maggie    Stiefvater

From BookLinks

OCTOBER 2009

Current Issue
Web Connections

Awards

Likely Stories
Book Group Buzz
Audiobooker
Bookends
Points of Reference

Reference updates

Atlas & Dictionary Update
Encyclopedia Update

Awards

Booklist Top of the List
Booklist Editors' Choice
Newbery Medal
Newbery Honor
Caldecott Medal
Caldecott Honor
Printz Award
Printz Honor
Sibert Medal
Sibert Honor
Coretta Scott King Award
Coretta Scott King Honor
Pura Belpre Award
Pura Belpre Honor
Stonewall Award
Stonewall Honor
Notable Books
The Reading List
Notable Children's Books
Amelia Bloomer
Odyssey Award
Odyssey Honor
Notable Media
Best Books for Young    Adults
Alex Awards
Rainbow List
Great Graphic Novels for    Teens
Quick Picks
Carnegie Medal
National Book Award
National Book Critics Circle    Award
Pulitzer Prize

Booklist citation and review
Add to List Download Print Email

Adult Books - Fiction - General Fiction

  Award winner

Disgrace.


Coetzee, J. M. (author).


Feb. 2000. 220p. Viking, hardcover, $23.95 (0-670-88731-5).
REVIEW. First published November 15, 1999 (Booklist).

In Waiting for the Barbarians (1980) and other great novels, the eminent South African writer Coetzee set his dark stories in a chaotic near-future world on the edge of allegory. The place in this book is postapartheid South Africa; the power struggle is now; anarchy has come. This deeply pessimistic view is how many conservatives today see the changes in South Africa. David Lurie, 52-year-old divorced literary scholar, is disgraced for sexually harassing one of his college students. Refusing to submit to “counseling,” he loses his job (he was never much of a teacher, anyway) and moves in with his beloved daughter Lucy on her small farm in the eastern Cape. She’s a sturdy peasant, part of the new world (“dogs and a gun; bread in the oven and a crop in the earth”) and he’s glad for her--until one night the farm is ransacked, the animals killed, and Lucy gang-raped. The predators will come back, but she refuses to leave (“They see me as owing something”). In the end, she will bear the child from that rape, become the third wife of her former sharecropper, and live on his land. With the social chaos is Lurie’s sense of personal failure. Is he also a monster? What about his own sexual aggression? Where is power now? There’s an ongoing metaphor about the poet Byron’s life and work that becomes tedious and self-indulgent--just too much about an idle old man “at the end of roving.” Like Lurie, Coetzee clearly sees himself as apolitical, a weary figure “from the margins of history,” but the insistence on violence as the only possibility makes the novel disappointing. What’s strongest in the story, as good as anything Coetzee has ever written, are the scenes in the country place, especially the father-daughter relationship (both tender and apart). This novel has just won the prestigious Booker Prize in England, making Coetzee the first writer ever to win the prize twice. (Reviewed November 15, 1999)— Hazel Rochman

 

 
Click here to find more books by this author
 
Find Similar Title

Features That Discuss This Work:
1. Notable Books : 2001

Log In

Username:
 
Password:
Perform Log In



BOOKLISTERS | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | GET REVIEWED | REVIEWERS | LINKS | FAQ | HELP | SUBSCRIBE

Booklist Online: Book Reviews from the American Library Association


Privacy Policy