|
|
Books For Youth - Fiction - Fantasy
|  |   | 
Coraline.
Gaiman, Neil (author).
Illustrated by Dave McKean.
July 2002. 176p. HarperCollins, hardcover, $15.99 (0-380-97778-8); library edition, $17.89 (0-06-623744-0). Grades 5-8.
REVIEW.
First published August, 2002 (Booklist).
Coraline has recently moved with her preoccupied parents into a flat in an old house. The neighbors above and below are odd but friendly: Mr. Bobo trains mice; elderly Misses Spink and Forcible serve her tea and tell her fortune. No one lives in the flat next door. But Coraline knows better, and one evening she discovers what’s there: a tantalizing alternate world, filled with toys and food (unlike any of the boring stuff she has at home) and weird-- though wonderfully attentive--parents, who happen to have black button eyes sewn on with dark thread. Although her “other parents” beg her to stay, she decides to leave, but by doing so Coraline sets in motion a host of nightmarish events that she must remedy alone. Gaiman, well known for his compelling adult horror novels (see “The Booklist Interview: Neil Gaiman”), seems less sure of himself with a younger age group. His “nowhere wonderland” setting (think Alice on acid) is magical, deliciously eerie, and well captured in the text and in McKean’s loose, angular sketches. But the goings-on are murky enough to puzzle some kids and certainly creepy enough to cause a few nightmares (ignore the publisher’s suggestion that this is suitable for eight-year-olds). What’s more, Coraline is no naive Alice. She’s a bundle of odd contradictions that never seem to gel--confident, outspoken, self-sufficient one moment; a whiny child the next. Gaiman’s construct offers a chilling and empowering view of children, to be sure, but young readers are likely to miss such subtleties as the clever allusions to classic horror movies and the references to the original dark tales by the Brothers Grimm. Gaiman has written an often-compelling horror novel, but, as with so many adult authors who attempt to reach young readers, his grasp of his audience is less sure than his command of his material. — Stephanie Zvirin
| |
|
| Click here to find more books by this author |
| |
|
|
Features That Discuss This Work:
1. Almost First Novels
2. Best Books for Young Adults : 2003
3. The Booklist Interview : Neil Gaiman
|
|
|
|
|